Most agency owners think pricing is one decision. It’s not. It’s three.

Every time you write a proposal, send a quote, or negotiate a deal, you’re actually answering three separate questions whether you realize it or not. The agencies that scale are the ones that answer all three intentionally and strategically.

Question 1: How do you decide what to charge?

This is the part most people think of as “pricing.” But there are fundamentally different ways to arrive at a number:

1. Start from your costs and work up. Add up what it costs you to deliver—labor, tools, overhead—and add a margin on top. You’ll never lose money on a project, but you’ll leave money on the table every time your work creates outsized value for the client. This works best when your costs are predictable and the work is commoditized. This is commonly known as cost-plus pricing.
2. Start from the market and adjust. Look at what others charge for similar work and price yourself in range. This is a safe way to enter a new market or establish a baseline, but it anchors you to someone else’s business model. If they’re underpricing, now you are too. This is commonly known as competitive pricing, market pricing, or industry pricing.
3. Start from the client's outcome and work backward. Figure out what the work is worth to the client—in revenue, savings, speed, risk reduction, etc—and [price as a fraction of that]/posts/pricing-profitable-projects/). If your rebrand helps them close $2M in new business, a $200K fee is a steal. This requires the skill to lead a value conversation with clients who think in terms of return on investment (ROI), but it's where the real leverage lives. This is commonly known as value-based pricing.
4. Let the results decide. Don’t set a fixed price at all. Take a percentage of sales, a commission on performance, or a revenue share tied to results. You’re betting on yourself and the client takes on less risk, which can make the deal easier to close. The danger is that you can’t control the client’s ability to execute on their end. This is commonly known as performance-based pricing.

Question 2: What is the client buying?

This is the packaging question. The client’s experience changes completely depending on how you package what they're getting.

1. They’re buying your time. Hours, days, availability, access… however you label it, the client is paying for your attention. This includes hourly billing, day rates, “fractional” roles, and retainers that are really just reserved calendar blocks. It’s simple and flexible, but it punishes efficiency, caps your income, and trains clients to watch the clock.
2. They’re buying a deliverable. A logo. A website. A slide deck. The client is paying for a defined artifact; the thing itself. They might not have a business outcome attached to it. They just need the asset. This is straightforward to scope and easy for the client to evaluate, but it commoditizes your work if you’re not careful.
3. They’re buying a transformation. Not the deliverable, but the result the deliverable produces. A rebrand that repositions them in the market. A design system that cuts their engineering costs by 30%. The client pays for the before-and-after, not the artifact. This is the highest leverage because your price scales with the impact, not your effort. It rewards strategic thinking and requires you to understand the client’s business deeply.

These tend to map to how agencies mature. You start selling time, graduate to selling deliverables, then learn to sell the transformation.

Question 3: How does the money get to you?

This is the part most agency owners set on autopilot and never reconsider. The structure of how money flows can change the entire dynamic of the relationship.

1. Up front. Full payment before work begins. You have zero cash flow risk. The client has maximum commitment. Works best when you have leverage and trust.
2. Installments. Fixed payments on a date schedule, not tied to deliverables or approvals. The client already agreed to the value; the installments are just how they pay for it. This keeps the focus on the project as a whole, not the individual artifacts.
3. Milestones. Payment tied to deliverable approvals. Be aware: this tells the client they’re buying the deliverable, not the transformation, no matter what you said in the sales call. Now the client has every right to nitpick, request revisions, and withhold payment until the deliverable is “right,” because that's the deal you made.
4. Recurring. Monthly or quarterly billing for ongoing work. Smooths out your cash flow, increases lifetime value, and reduces the feast-or-famine cycle. This can sit on top of time, deliverables, or transformation.
5. On performance. You get paid as results come in: a percentage of sales, a commission per unit, a bonus when targets are hit. You’re sharing the risk and the upside with the client. This can make deals easier to close but harder to predict.
6. Equity or trade. You accept ownership, stock, or barter instead of cash. This only makes sense if you believe in the client’s upside more than you need the cash today.

How the Three Questions Work Together

Every project you win requires an answer to each question. Here are a few common combinations:

• A freelancer early in their career might price from the market, sell their time, and bill monthly. Safe, predictable, easy for clients to say yes to.
• A scaling agency might price from the client’s outcome, sell a defined deliverable, and bill in installments. Higher revenue per project, more leverage, and a contract that doesn’t undermine the value conversation.
• A senior consultant might price from the client's outcome, sell the transformation itself, and bill on a recurring retainer. Predictable recurring revenue tied to strategic value.
• A growth partner might let results decide, sell the transformation, and get paid on performance. Maximum alignment with the client, but maximum exposure to their execution.

None of these combinations are inherently better or worse. The right one depends on your unfair advantages, where you are, what you’re selling, and what your business needs right now.

The Strategic Levers

On top of your three answers, there are temporary moves you can make depending on what you're optimizing for in a given moment:

• If you need market share or case studies, you might deliberately underprice for a period to build volume and social proof then raise prices once you’ve established a foothold.
• If you have more demand than capacity, you might raise prices during peak periods or for rush timelines, extracting more from each engagement when the market allows it.
• If you want to attract a specific caliber of client, you might price high on purpose, using the price itself as a filter for buyers who equate cost with quality.

These aren’t permanent pricing decisions. They’re dials you can turn up or down based on what your business needs this quarter.

The Big Idea

Pricing isn’t a single choice you make once. It’s three questions you answer together, and the answers should evolve as your business does.

Most agency owners default into a combination early—usually market-based pricing, selling time, payable on milestones—and never revisit it. That combination works when you’re starting out, but you can quickly outgrow it as you build reputation.

The unlock isn’t learning a fancier methodology. It’s realizing that you have three levers, not one, and that changing any one of them can change the whole equation.

Join 66,800+ subscribers to the weekly Dan Mall Teaches newsletter. I promise to keep my communication light and valuable!